Small Business Tips

W2 vs. W4: What's the Difference?

Stephen Fishman
Tax expert and contributor MileIQ

There are hundreds of IRS forms, but, if your business has employees, two of the most important are Forms W-2 and W-4. Employers use these forms to help follow the pay-as-you-go tax system the United States follows. However, there’s an important distinction between W-2 vs. W-4 forms other than just the number at the end. Let's go over the major difference between W-2 and W-4.

What’s the major difference between IRS W-2 vs W-4 forms?

The difference between a W-2 and W-4 is that a W-4 is completed by the employee and used by employers to calculate how much income tax to withhold. The purpose of the W-2 is to report employee pay over the past year and how much tax was withheld.

What is a W-4 used for?

Form W-4 is the Employee's Withholding Allowance Certificate. Employers use this to calculate how much income tax to withhold from the employee's pay throughout their employment. (It has no impact on how much Social Security or Medicare tax is withheld). To comply with the policy, employees must complete and sign this form on or before the day they begin a new job. New employees cannot use the same Form W-4 they filed with a prior employer. A new W-4 must be completed, even though it will usually be the same as the employee's previous W-4. The company should keep the completed W-4 on file; it need not be filed with the IRS unless the IRS asks for it. Form W-4 is important because it tells the employer:

     

Download MileIQ to start tracking your drives

Automatic, accurate mileage reports.

  • Whether to withhold income tax from the employee's pay at the single rate or lower married rate
  •  
  • How many withholding allowances the employee claims (each allowance reduces the amount withheld)
  •  
  • Whether the employee wants an extra amount withheld, and whether the employee claims to be exempt from withholding
  •  
  • The employee should make the form effective with the first wage payment

If there's no completed W-4, the employer must withhold income tax as if the employee is single. This means there are no withholding allowances.  This means that the largest amount must be withheld until the employee provides a completed W-4. Form W-4 remains in effect until the employee gives the employer a new one. Yet, employees who claim to be exempt from withholding must complete a new Form W-4 each year.  If an employee's tax situation changes, they must provide the employer with a new updated W-4. It's up to the employee to complete his or her W-4. Employers need not verify the allowances or withholding exemptions claimed by the employee. Employees who need help with the form can use the online IRS withholding allowance calculator.

What is a W-2 form used for?

IRS Form W-2, Wage and Tax Statement, is an information return that must be completed and filed by employers each year. It is not used to pay or withhold tax. Instead, it reports how much the employee was paid during the year and how much tax was withheld.  Every employer engaged in business must file a Form W-2 for each employee who is paid cash or non-cash compensation. That is so no matter how much pay the employee received. That is, there no minimum dollar amount that triggers this reporting obligation.  Yet, household employers generally file Form W-2 only if wages equal or exceed the payroll tax threshold for household wages ($2,000 in 2016). A W-2 must be filed even if the employee is related to you. For example, if you hire your spouse or child to work in your business.  Form W-2 is a six-part form. The employer must file a copy of with the Social Security Administration and another with the applicable state tax agency. You must send three copies of the form to the employee. Employees who file their income taxes on paper must attach a copy of the W-2 with their return. One copy should be maintained by the employer. The due date for filing is January 31 of each year.  Completing the W-2 form can be tricky because the amount of employee wages can include amounts other than cash wages. For example, such items as non-cash compensation, dependent care assistance benefits, scholarships, employer-provided group-term life insurance, certain expense arrangements, and tips.

Getting Help with Payroll Taxes

Payroll taxes can quickly get complicated, especially when you have to figure out W-4 vs. W-2 form requirements. You have to calculate the withholding, do the necessary record keeping and fill out the required forms. Because of this, many small business owners rely on tax pros or accountants to do it. Remember, the amounts you pay a payroll tax service are deductible business operating expenses. You can also handle payroll and taxes yourself using accounting software.

Download MileIQ to start tracking your drives

Automatic, accurate mileage reports.

Are you tracking your miles yet?

Use MileIQ to keep a full, IRS friendly mileage log.
Sign Up